Strip away the theory and a large proportion of episodes reduce to the same scene: alone, evening, nothing on, tired but not sleepy, no plan.
That scene is the actual problem. Everything else is downstream.
You cannot willpower your way through an unstructured empty evening indefinitely. You can restructure the evening.
What helps, in rough order of effectiveness:
Put things in the diary. Not aspirations — commitments with other people in them, at fixed times. A weekly sport, a class, a standing call. Recurring beats spontaneous because it doesn't require wanting it on the day.
Have a default. A decided-in-advance answer to "what am I doing tonight?" A series you're working through. A book on the table. Somewhere you walk. Undecided time is the danger, more than any specific trigger.
Front-load the evening. What you do between 6 and 8 determines what happens between 10 and 12 far more than any resolution made at 10.
Take loneliness seriously as a problem in its own right. Problematic use tracks with loneliness in the research, though the studies are cross-sectional, so which way it runs is guesswork. The intuitive reading — using instead of connecting makes connecting harder, which makes using more likely — is plausible and unproven. If you're in that spiral, the intervention isn't better urge management. It's the slower work of putting people back in the week. That isn't a lesson in an app, and it doesn't happen quickly. It's still the thing that works.
Takeaways
- Undecided time is more dangerous than any specific trigger.
- 6 to 8pm decides 10 to 12 far more than any resolution made at 10.
- Loneliness is its own problem, and better urge management won't touch it.
In the app, this lesson ends with a practice
Look at the next seven evenings. Which are unstructured?
Sources and how strong they are (2)
- Well establishedProblematic pornography use tracks distress better than overall frequency of use does. People who use frequently without distress and people who use frequently with it are distinguishable, and it is the problematic group that differs on mental-health measures - most clearly on depressive symptoms and self-esteem.Bothe et al. 2020, J Sex Med 17(4):793-811, doi:10.1016/j.jsxm.2020.01.007
- Mixed evidenceIncreasing the friction of a behaviour - moving the cue further away, reducing availability, breaking the sequence that leads to it - reduces how often it occurs. The direction is consistently found and the effects are moderate, but the evidence is graded low-certainty, comes mostly from short laboratory studies of food, and has never been compared head-to-head with intention-based approaches. What is separately well established is that intentions on their own translate weakly into behaviour.Hollands et al. 2019, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews CD012573.pub3, doi:10.1002/14651858.CD012573.pub3, PMID 31482606
Questions this lesson answers
The app adds Panic.
One tap for the moment an urge hits, offline, and an evening check-in that turns lessons like this one into a plan for your own triggers. Free.
Coming to iOS and Android.